Process & DFM

Thread Galling: Why Stainless and Titanium Threads Seize, and How to Stop It

A stainless bolt that locks up halfway into a stainless nut has galled. It is predictable, and the fixes are cheap if they are on the drawing before the parts are made.

Tom PetriniCo-founder, OpenSpindle
Published 7 min read
NUTBOLTNUTBOLTCOLD WELDED, MATERIAL TORNFILM KEEPS BARE METAL APART304 ON 304, DRYOXIDE WIPED OFF, FLANKS BONDANTI-SEIZE ON THE FLANKSSAME THREADS, FLANKS SEPARATEDGALLING STARTS WHERE BARE FLANKS TOUCH

The short answer

Galling is adhesive wear: under pressure and sliding, the thin oxide film on two metal surfaces is wiped away, bare metal touches, and the high spots cold weld and tear material from one surface onto the other. In threads it makes a fastener seize partway in. Stainless steel, titanium and aluminum are most prone. Anti-seize, dissimilar or harder mating alloys, coatings and slower installation prevent it.

What galling is

Galling is a form of adhesive wear. Two metal surfaces under load slide against each other; the high points on each surface, the asperities, carry the load at tiny contact spots where the local pressure is very high. If those spots are bare metal, they bond. Further sliding tears the bonded junctions apart, but not at the original interface: a chunk of one surface stays welded to the other. The transferred lump plows a deeper groove, which raises friction and heat, which creates more junctions.

In a thread, that runaway happens in a fraction of a turn. Torque climbs, the fastener stops, and trying to back it out usually tears the threads further. The parts are typically scrap: the bolt has to be cut out, and the internal thread may need to be drilled and repaired with an insert.

Galling is different from cross-threading, though both stop a screw. A cross-threaded screw went in crooked and cut new threads; a galled screw went in straight and welded itself to the mating thread.

Why stainless, titanium and aluminum gall

Most metals carry a thin surface oxide that keeps bare metal apart. Stainless steel, titanium and aluminum are corrosion resistant because their oxide film is thin, tough and self-healing. It is also very thin, and under the contact pressure of a loaded thread flank it gets wiped off faster than it can reform.

Under the film, these alloys have properties that make bonding easy:

  • Ductility and work hardening. Austenitic stainless such as 304 and 316 deforms readily at the asperities, enlarging the contact area, and work hardens so the transferred material is harder than the surface it plows.
  • Like on like. Two parts of the same alloy and hardness have the same crystal structure and bond readily. A 304 bolt in a 304 nut is the classic galling pair.
  • Low thermal conductivity. Stainless and titanium hold frictional heat at the flank, which softens the surface and accelerates bonding.

Carbon steel fasteners gall far less, partly because of their oxide and plating and partly because they are usually harder than what they thread into. That is why galling surprises people the first time a design switches to stainless.

What makes it worse

Galling needs load, sliding and clean metal. Anything that adds one of those raises the risk.

FactorWhy it matters
Same alloy and hardness on both partsSimilar surfaces bond readily, and neither one is hard enough to resist the other
Dry threadsNo film separating the flanks once the oxide wipes off
Fast installation (power drivers, impact tools)Frictional heat builds faster than it conducts away
High preload or long thread engagementMore flank pressure over more sliding distance
Fine threads and tight thread classesLess clearance between flanks and more turns to install
Damaged, dirty or burred threadsDebris and burrs start the first junctions
Reused fastenersEarlier micro-damage on the flanks seeds new galling

How to prevent galling

The fixes either keep the flanks apart, make the surfaces different, or reduce the heat and pressure. Combining two of them is common on critical joints.

Anti-seize or thread lubricant. The cheapest and most effective single step. Nickel-based anti-seize is a common choice for stainless and high-temperature joints; molybdenum disulfide pastes are widely used on titanium and stainless. Copper-based compounds are common on carbon steel; for stainless and titanium, many suppliers recommend nickel-based or metal-free grades instead, particularly at high temperature. Check compatibility with your environment, for example oxygen service, food contact or vacuum.

Dissimilar alloys or hardness. Pair materials that do not bond as readily, or make one part noticeably harder. A frequently cited guideline is a hardness difference of at least about 50 Brinell between mating parts. Combinations such as a 300-series bolt in a 400-series or precipitation hardened stainless nut, or a stainless bolt in a bronze or silicon bronze nut, are common in service.

Galling-resistant alloys. Nitronic 60 (UNS S21800) is an austenitic stainless with added silicon and manganese, developed in part for galling resistance, and is used for nuts, bushings, valve stems and wear parts that slide against other stainless. It costs more and is less widely stocked than 304 or 316, so shops may need lead time to source it.

Coatings and platings. Silver plating on nuts, dry film lubricants (PTFE or molybdenum disulfide based), nitriding and, for titanium, anodize or other surface treatments separate the flanks or harden the surface. Coatings add thickness, so the thread class and plating allowance need to be on the drawing.

Slower, controlled installation. Hand tighten or use a low-speed driver, and stop if torque rises unexpectedly. Backing off a quarter turn and adding lubricant can save a joint that is starting to bind.

Coarse threads and looser classes. Coarse series threads (UNC, metric coarse) have more clearance per flank and need fewer turns. A class 2A/2B or 6g/6H fit is usually less prone to galling than a class 3A/3B fit.

Thread inserts. In aluminum or other soft parent material, a helical coil or key-locking insert gives the screw a hard, smooth stainless thread to run in and protects the parent thread from repeated assembly. Note that a stainless screw in a stainless insert is still a like-on-like pair; lubricant or a coated or dry-film-lubricated insert helps there.

Galling in titanium and aluminum

Titanium galls readily against itself and against stainless, and it is often specified in exactly the places where seizure is expensive: aerospace, medical and motorsport hardware. Titanium-on-titanium threads without a lubricant or coating are a known risk. Common practice is a dry film lubricant or anodize on one part, molybdenum disulfide or another titanium-compatible anti-seize at assembly, and controlled torque.

Aluminum galls against itself and against stainless, and in aluminum the softer part usually loses: the parent thread strips or tears. For threads that see repeated assembly, a stainless insert is the standard fix. For sliding fits rather than threads, hard anodize on one surface is the usual approach.

For material selection beyond threads, see stainless steel and titanium.

What to put on the drawing

Galling is usually decided by details a shop will not infer from the model. Put these on the drawing or in the RFQ note:

  • Material and condition of each mating part, including the fastener, not only the machined part. If the bolt and the tapped part are both 316, the shop can flag it.
  • Thread specification and class, for example 1/4-20 UNC-2B or M6x1-6H, plus any plating or coating allowance.
  • Lubricant or anti-seize at assembly, named by product or specification, for example NICKEL ANTI-SEIZE PER MIL-PRF-907 OR EQUIVALENT ON ALL STAINLESS THREADS.
  • Torque, stated as lubricated or dry. Anti-seize lowers friction, so the same torque produces noticeably more preload than on dry threads. A dry torque value applied to lubricated threads can overload the bolt.
  • Inserts with part number or type and length, if the parent material is soft or the thread sees repeated assembly.
  • Coatings such as silver plate or dry film lubricant, with the specification, on whichever part carries it.

If a shop is assembling the parts, add an installation note such as HAND START, INSTALL AT LOW SPEED. If you are assembling them yourself, those same notes belong in your work instruction.

How galling prevention affects cost

Most of these fixes are inexpensive when they are designed in. Anti-seize at assembly adds very little. Switching a nut to a different stainless grade or bronze usually changes only the purchased hardware. Thread inserts add a secondary operation and hardware cost per hole. Nitronic 60 bar stock and silver or dry film coatings cost more and can add lead time, because fewer suppliers stock or process them.

The expensive version is discovering galling at assembly: cut-out fasteners, scrapped parts and repaired threads. If your assembly pairs stainless with stainless or titanium with titanium, flag it on the RFQ. The matched shop can suggest the lowest-cost fix for its process before parts are cut.

Sources

  • ASTM G98, Standard Test Method for Galling Resistance of Materials
  • MIL-PRF-907, Antiseize Thread Compound, High Temperature
  • ASM Handbook, Volume 18: Friction, Lubrication, and Wear Technology
  • Nitronic 60 (UNS S21800) producer data sheet

Last reviewed by Tom Petrini

Let us quote your next part.

Upload your CAD or drawing and tell us your budget. We source it across our global network of partner shops and come back with your best-match quote, typically within about 24 hours.

  • Free quote in about 24 hours
  • No minimum order
  • No account needed to start
Add your CAD filesUp to 30 files per quote
Upload files & get a free quote

STEP · STL · IGES · DWG · DXF · SLDPRT · and more

No CAD file? Describe your project instead

Frequently asked questions

What is galling?

Galling is adhesive wear between two sliding metal surfaces under load. The protective oxide film is wiped off, bare metal touches, and the high spots cold weld and tear material from one surface onto the other. In threaded fasteners, it causes the bolt to seize partway in.

Why do stainless steel bolts gall?

Stainless steel relies on a very thin chromium oxide film that is easily wiped off under thread pressure. Austenitic grades such as 304 and 316 are ductile, work harden and hold heat at the surface, so bare metal junctions form and grow quickly. A stainless bolt in a stainless nut of the same grade is a classic galling pair.

How do you prevent thread galling?

Use anti-seize or a thread lubricant, pair dissimilar alloys or hardnesses, use a galling-resistant alloy such as Nitronic 60, apply a coating such as silver plate or dry film lubricant, install slowly, and prefer coarse threads and standard thread classes. Thread inserts protect soft parent material.

Does anti-seize change the torque I should use?

Yes. Anti-seize lowers thread friction, so the same torque produces more clamp load than on dry threads. Specify whether a torque value is lubricated or dry, and use the lubricated value from your fastener or lubricant data when anti-seize is applied.

Can a galled bolt be saved?

Rarely. Stop as soon as torque rises unexpectedly; backing off slightly, cleaning and lubricating can sometimes free a joint that is just starting to bind. A fully seized fastener usually has to be cut out, and the internal thread repaired, often with a thread insert.

Does titanium gall?

Yes. Titanium galls readily against itself and against stainless steel. Typical prevention is a dry film lubricant or anodize on one part, a titanium-compatible anti-seize such as a molybdenum disulfide paste at assembly, and controlled torque.