Materials

Hot Rolled vs Cold Rolled Steel: Which Mild Steel to Specify

A36, HRPO and cold rolled or cold drawn 1018 compared by surface, tolerance, flatness, residual stress and cost, with a pick for each process.

Tom PetriniCo-founder, OpenSpindle
Published 7 min read
Hot Rolled vs Cold Rolled Steel: Which Mild Steel to Specify

The short answer

Hot rolled steel, such as A36, is finished at high temperature, so it carries mill scale, looser thickness tolerance and less flatness, but it costs the least. Cold rolled or cold drawn steel, such as 1018, is reduced further at room temperature for a smooth surface, tighter tolerance and, in bar, higher strength. HRPO is hot rolled with the scale pickled off. Use hot rolled for structure and plate, HRPO for clean laser-cut and coated parts, and cold rolled for thin precise sheet and machined bar.

What mild steel is, and where A36 and 1018 fit

Mild steel is the everyday name for low-carbon steel: plain iron-carbon steel with roughly 0.05 to 0.25 percent carbon and small amounts of manganese. Low carbon makes it ductile, easy to weld and easy to form, but it cannot be through-hardened much by heat treatment. It is the default metal for brackets, frames, enclosures, plates and weldments when the part will be painted, powder coated or plated.

Two names cover most of what buyers order:

  • A36 is an ASTM structural specification, not a chemistry. It guarantees a 36 ksi (250 MPa) minimum yield and a 58 to 80 ksi tensile range, with loose chemistry limits. It is sold hot rolled, in plate, structural shapes and bar.
  • 1018 is an SAE/AISI chemistry (about 0.15 to 0.20 percent carbon, 0.60 to 0.90 percent manganese). It is most often bought as cold drawn bar for machining.

For thinner sheet, the common hot rolled spec is usually ASTM A1011 and cold rolled sheet is usually ASTM A1008, both in commercial steel (CS) or structural steel (SS) grades. Hot rolled and cold rolled describe how the steel was finished at the mill, which is a separate question from the grade.

How hot rolled, HRPO and cold rolled are made

Hot rolled (HR). The steel is rolled to size while it is well above its recrystallization temperature, typically finished above about 1,500 °F (815 °C), then cooled in air. As it cools it forms a blue-gray iron oxide skin called mill scale, and it shrinks slightly and unevenly, so final size and flatness are less controlled.

Hot rolled, pickled and oiled (HRPO or P&O). Hot rolled sheet or coil run through an acid bath to strip the mill scale, then coated with a light oil so it does not rust in storage. Tolerances and strength are the same as hot rolled; the surface is clean dull gray.

Cold rolled (CR) and cold drawn (CD). Pickled hot rolled steel is reduced further at room temperature, by rolling for sheet and strip or drawing through a die for bar. Sheet is usually annealed and given a light temper pass afterward, so its strength ends up close to hot rolled but its surface, tolerance and flatness are much better. Cold drawn bar is usually not annealed, so it keeps the work hardening and comes out noticeably stronger than hot rolled bar of the same grade.

Side-by-side comparison

PropertyHot rolled (A36, A1011)HRPOCold rolled sheet (A1008) / cold drawn bar (1018 CD)
SurfaceBlue-gray mill scale, roughClean dull gray, oiledSmooth, bright, oiled
Thickness or size toleranceLoosestSame as hot rolledNoticeably tighter
Flatness and squarenessLeast flat; bar has rounded cornersSame as hot rolledFlatter sheet; sharp, square bar edges
Yield strength (typical)A36: 250 MPa (36 ksi) minSame as hot rolled gradeCR sheet: similar to HR. 1018 CD bar: about 370 MPa (54 ksi)
Residual stressLower, but cooling stresses existSame as hot rolledHigher near the surface of cold drawn bar
Rust behavior in storageScale slows rust until it cracksRusts once oil is removedRusts once oil is removed
Relative costLowestSmall premium over HRHighest of the three

Exact tolerances are set by ASTM A6 (plate and shapes), A568 (sheet) and A108/A29 (bar) and depend on thickness and width. Ask the shop if a dimension depends on raw stock size.

Residual stress: why cold drawn bar moves when you machine it

Cold drawing compresses the outside of a bar and leaves balanced locked-in stresses between surface and core. Machine material off one side, cut a long slot, or turn a thin-walled sleeve, and the balance changes: the part bows or twists as the remaining stresses redistribute.

That is why a 1018 CD flat bar that was straight on the rack can come off the mill with a bow you can see. Shops manage it by roughing, letting the part relax, then finishing, or by machining both sides evenly. For long, asymmetric or tight-flatness parts, the better buy is often hot rolled bar with extra stock to clean up, stress-relieved cold drawn bar, or precision ground flat stock.

Hot rolled plate is not stress free either. Cooling and leveling leave stress that can make plate spring when it is burned or deeply pocketed, though it is usually milder than in cold drawn bar. If flatness is critical on a laser-cut or plasma-cut plate part, say so; the shop may recommend a leveled or stress-relieved plate.

Which to pick, by process

ProcessUsual pickWhy
Laser cutting thin sheet (up to about 3 mm)Cold rolled (A1008) or HRPOClean surface gives consistent pierce and edge quality and less dross
Laser, plasma or waterjet cutting plateHRPO where available, A36 hot rolled for thick plateMill scale can cause inconsistent pierces and spatter; HR is the economical choice for heavy plate
Bending in a press brakeCold rolled for tight radii, HR or HRPO for brackets and structureCR forms around 0.5 to 1x thickness; scale can flake at HR bends
WeldingAny; clean the jointLow carbon welds easily, but scale and oil in the joint cause porosity, especially with TIG
Machining1018 CD for small precise parts; HR bar for heavy stock removalCD holds size and finish; HR has less residual stress but needs a cleanup allowance
Paint or powder coatHRPO or cold rolledMill scale under a coating can let go later and take the coating with it

These are common defaults, not rules. Partner shops sometimes substitute based on what they stock; if the condition matters to the part, put it on the drawing.

Mill scale and finishing

Mill scale is hard and brittle, and it bonds to the steel poorly enough that it eventually cracks and flakes, particularly where a part is bent or flexes. If you paint or powder coat over it, the coating is only as attached as the scale is.

For coated parts, either buy HRPO or cold rolled, or have the shop remove scale by blasting or pickling before coating. Both add cost on hot rolled stock, so it is usually cheaper to start with HRPO. For hot-dip galvanizing, the galvanizer pickles the steel as part of the process, so hot rolled is usually fine.

One laser-specific note: steel cut with oxygen assist leaves a thin oxide layer on the cut edge, regardless of the starting surface. If edge adhesion matters for the coating, ask for nitrogen-cut edges or edge prep, and see our mild steel vs stainless comparison for when an uncoated stainless part is the simpler answer.

What to put on the drawing or RFQ

"Mild steel" or "CRS" alone leaves the choice to the shop. That is fine for a bracket that gets powder coated; it is not fine if strength, flatness or appearance matters. A clear callout names the spec, the condition, and the thickness in decimal units rather than gauge.

  • Structural plate: ASTM A36, hot rolled, 0.375 in.
  • Laser-cut and powder-coated sheet: ASTM A1011 CS Type B, HRPO, 0.120 in.
  • Thin precise sheet or tight bends: ASTM A1008 CS Type B, cold rolled, 0.060 in.
  • Machined bar: 1018 cold drawn per ASTM A108, or hot rolled 1018 if flatness after heavy machining matters more than stock size.

Add a mill test report request if the part is structural or traceable. More on the alloys themselves is on our carbon steel material page.

Sources

  • ASTM A36, Carbon Structural Steel
  • ASTM A1011, Steel, Sheet and Strip, Hot-Rolled, Carbon, Structural, HSLA
  • ASTM A1008, Steel, Sheet, Cold-Rolled, Carbon, Structural, HSLA
  • ASTM A568, General Requirements for Steel Sheet, Carbon, Structural, and HSLA
  • ASTM A6, General Requirements for Rolled Structural Steel Bars, Plates, Shapes, and Sheet Piling
  • ASTM A108, Steel Bar, Carbon and Alloy, Cold-Finished
  • MatWeb material property data

Last reviewed by Tom Petrini

Let us quote your next part.

Upload your CAD or drawing and tell us your budget. We source it across our global network of partner shops and come back with your best-match quote, typically within about 24 hours.

  • Free quote in about 24 hours
  • No minimum order
  • No account needed to start
Add your CAD filesUp to 30 files per quote
Upload files & get a free quote

STEP · STL · IGES · DWG · DXF · SLDPRT · and more

No CAD file? Describe your project instead

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between hot rolled and cold rolled steel?

Hot rolled steel is rolled to size at high temperature and cools with mill scale, looser tolerances and less flatness. Cold rolled steel is further reduced at room temperature, giving a smooth surface, tighter tolerances and better flatness. Cold drawn bar is also stronger than hot rolled bar of the same grade, while cold rolled sheet is usually annealed to near hot rolled strength.

What is mild steel?

Mild steel is low-carbon steel, roughly 0.05 to 0.25 percent carbon. It is ductile, easy to weld and form, inexpensive, and rusts without a coating. A36, 1018, 1020 and A1008/A1011 sheet grades are the common forms.

Is A36 hot rolled or cold rolled?

A36 is produced hot rolled, as plate, structural shapes and bar. It is a strength specification (36 ksi minimum yield) rather than a chemistry. Cold finished bar is normally ordered by chemistry, such as 1018, instead of A36.

What is HRPO steel?

Hot rolled, pickled and oiled. It is hot rolled sheet or coil with the mill scale removed in an acid bath and a light oil applied to prevent rust. It keeps hot rolled tolerances and price close to hot rolled, with a clean surface that laser cuts, welds and powder coats well.

Is cold rolled steel stronger than hot rolled?

Cold drawn bar is, typically about 370 MPa (54 ksi) yield for 1018 CD against about 220 MPa (32 ksi) for hot rolled 1018. Cold rolled sheet is usually annealed after rolling, so its strength is close to hot rolled sheet; you buy it for surface, tolerance and formability.

Which steel is best for laser cutting?

For thin sheet, cold rolled or HRPO, because the clean surface gives consistent cuts. For plate, HRPO where available, or A36 hot rolled for heavy plate where cost matters more than cut cosmetics.