The short answer
Titanium (Ti-6Al-4V) weighs about 45 percent less than stainless steel and is roughly four times as strong as annealed 304, so it wins on strength-to-weight and in seawater. Stainless is stiffer, cheaper, easier to machine and weld, and hardened grades like 17-4 PH and 440C are harder than titanium. Choose titanium when weight, chloride corrosion or implant use drives the design; otherwise stainless is usually the better buy.
The numbers
"Stainless" covers a wide range, so the table compares the workhorse titanium alloy with the two stainless grades buyers most often weigh it against: annealed 304 and precipitation-hardened 17-4 PH.
| Property (typical) | Ti-6Al-4V (Grade 5), annealed | 304 stainless, annealed | 17-4 PH, H900 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Density | 4.43 g/cm³ | 8.00 g/cm³ | 7.80 g/cm³ |
| Yield strength | 880 MPa (128 ksi) | 215 MPa (31 ksi) | 1170 MPa (170 ksi) min |
| Tensile strength | 950 MPa (138 ksi) | 505 MPa (73 ksi) | 1310 MPa (190 ksi) min |
| Specific strength (yield / density) | About 199 | About 27 | About 150 |
| Hardness | About 36 HRC | About 70 to 90 HRB (below 20 HRC) | 40 HRC min, typically 40 to 47 |
| Elastic modulus (stiffness) | About 114 GPa | About 193 GPa | About 197 GPa |
| Thermal conductivity | 6.7 W/m·K | 16.2 W/m·K | About 18 W/m·K |
| Magnetic | No | No when annealed, slightly after cold work | Yes |
| Relative machinability | Poor | Fair (work hardens) | Fair |
Yield and tensile for 17-4 H900 are ASTM A564 minimums; the rest are typical published values. Specific strength is in MPa per g/cm³.
Is titanium harder than steel?
It depends on which steel, and on which titanium.
- Ti-6Al-4V vs annealed stainless. Yes. Grade 5 titanium runs about 36 HRC. Annealed 304 and 316 sit around 70 to 90 HRB, which is below the bottom of the Rockwell C scale. Grade 5 is also harder than mild steel.
- Commercially pure titanium vs stainless. Roughly a tie. Grade 2 CP titanium is in the same soft range as annealed austenitic stainless.
- Titanium vs hardened stainless and tool steel. No. 17-4 PH in H900 is 40 HRC or more, hardened 440C typically reaches the high 50s HRC, and hardened tool steels run 58 to 65 HRC.
Hardness also is not the same thing as wear resistance. Titanium scratches, galls and wears in sliding contact more readily than its hardness number suggests, which is why titanium sliding surfaces are often coated or anodized. If the question behind "harder" is "will it hold up in a wear application", the answer is usually a hardened steel, not titanium.
Weight and stiffness: the trade most people miss
Titanium saves weight only if you use its strength. A part of identical geometry is about 45 percent lighter in titanium. But titanium's elastic modulus is a bit under 60 percent of stainless, so the same part also deflects about 1.7 times as much under the same load.
For a strength-limited part (it must not yield), titanium lets you shrink sections and the weight savings compound. For a stiffness-limited part (it must not flex: a mounting plate, a long arm, a precision fixture), thinning the section makes deflection worse, and stainless or even aluminum can be the lighter answer for the same stiffness. Know which one limits your design before you pay for titanium.
Corrosion, heat and biocompatibility
Corrosion. Both form a passive oxide film. Titanium's film is far more resistant to chlorides: it resists pitting and crevice corrosion in seawater at ordinary temperatures, where 304 pits and 316 eventually does. Titanium is vulnerable to a few specific chemicals, notably hydrofluoric acid and some hot reducing acids, so check a corrosion table for chemical service.
Heat. Ti-6Al-4V is typically used up to about 400 °C. Austenitic stainless resists oxidation to roughly 870 °C in continuous service, though its strength drops well before that. For hot parts without a weight constraint, stainless or a nickel alloy usually wins.
Biocompatibility. Ti-6Al-4V ELI (ASTM F136) and CP titanium (ASTM F67) are the standard implant metals for long-term use. 316LVM (ASTM F138) is also an implant-grade stainless, more common in temporary devices. Surgical instruments are mostly hardened martensitic or PH stainless, because they need an edge and hardness more than they need titanium's properties.
What titanium does to a quote compared with stainless
Stainless is not a cheap metal to machine either, so the gap is smaller than titanium vs aluminum. The premium comes from three places.
- Material. Ti-6Al-4V bar costs several times 304 per pound. Titanium's lower density offsets part of that, because a given part uses about 45 percent fewer pounds.
- Cycle time. Titanium runs at lower surface speeds than 304 and holds heat at the tool edge (6.7 W/m·K against about 16), so tools wear faster.
- Availability. 304, 316 and 17-4 are stocked in most sizes by most metal service centers. Titanium plate and large bar are held by fewer distributors, which can add days to lead time.
| Cost component | 304 or 316 stainless | Ti-6Al-4V |
|---|---|---|
| Raw material, per part | 1x | Typically 3 to 6x |
| Cycle time | 1x | Typically 1.5 to 3x |
| Tooling consumed | Moderate | Higher |
| Typical finished machined part | 1x | Roughly 2 to 5x |
| Lead time | Standard | Often longer for plate and large bar |
Multipliers are directional and vary with geometry, quantity and market price. Stock-heavy parts (lots of material removed) push toward the top of the range; small, simple parts narrow it.
Galling and threads
Both metals gall. Austenitic stainless threads are notorious for seizing when a stainless bolt goes into a stainless nut, and titanium on titanium is worse. The surfaces cold weld under pressure and the fastener locks or tears.
The fixes are the same for both: anti-seize or a dry-film lubricant, a dissimilar mating material or hardness, a galling-resistant alloy such as Nitronic 60 for one side of the pair, or a wire thread insert. Slower installation speed helps with power tools. If the part has threads that will be assembled and disassembled, say so on the RFQ so the shop can flag it. Our thread galling guide covers the options in detail.
Welding
Austenitic stainless is one of the easier metals to weld. Specify the low-carbon L grades (304L, 316L) for welded parts to avoid sensitization, where chromium carbides form at grain boundaries and the heat-affected zone loses corrosion resistance.
Titanium welds well but only under full inert-gas coverage, including a trailing shield and a back purge, because hot titanium absorbs oxygen and nitrogen and becomes brittle. Weld color is the field check: bright silver to light straw is generally acceptable, while blue, gray or white indicates contamination that most specs reject. Fewer shops are set up for production titanium welding, which narrows the supplier pool and adds cost.
17-4 PH is weldable but needs post-weld heat treatment to restore its properties, so plan the weld before the final age.
When titanium earns it, and when stainless is the answer
Titanium is worth the premium when at least one of these is a real requirement:
- Strength-to-weight on a strength-limited part, such as aerospace brackets, racing and cycling components, and handheld or worn devices.
- Seawater, brine or chloride exposure where 316 has pitted or is likely to.
- Long-term implants.
- A nonmagnetic part that also has to be strong.
- Galvanic compatibility with carbon fiber.
Stainless is the better buy for most everything else: food and process equipment, enclosures, shafts, fixtures, fasteners, hot parts, stiffness-limited parts, and wear parts in a hardened grade. If no one can name the property that requires titanium, quote it in 304, 316 or 17-4 first.
On the drawing, call out the grade and spec rather than "titanium" or "stainless": for example Ti-6Al-4V per ASTM B348 or AMS 4928, 316L per ASTM A276, or 17-4 PH per AMS 5643, heat treated to H1025. The condition changes hardness and strength enough to change the quote.
Sources
- ASTM B348, Titanium and Titanium Alloy Bars and Billets
- ASTM A564, Hot-Rolled and Cold-Finished Age-Hardening Stainless Steel Bars and Shapes
- ASTM A240, Chromium and Chromium-Nickel Stainless Steel Plate, Sheet, and Strip
- ASTM F136, Wrought Titanium-6Aluminum-4Vanadium ELI Alloy for Surgical Implant Applications
- ASTM F138, Wrought 18Chromium-14Nickel-2.5Molybdenum Stainless Steel Bar and Wire for Surgical Implants
- AWS D17.1, Specification for Fusion Welding for Aerospace Applications
- ASM Handbook, Volumes 1 and 2 (ASM International)
- MatWeb material property data
Last reviewed by Tom Petrini
