The short answer
Polycarbonate vs acrylic comes down to impact. Polycarbonate (Lexan, Makrolon) is roughly 30 times tougher by notched Izod and bends where acrylic cracks, so it is the choice for guards and shields. Acrylic (Plexiglas, Lucite) is clearer, harder to scratch, UV stable and cheaper, and it laser cuts to a polished edge. Polycarbonate discolors under a CO2 laser, so it is usually routed, machined or waterjet cut.
The numbers
| Property | Acrylic (PMMA) | Polycarbonate (PC) |
|---|---|---|
| Common brand names | Plexiglas, Acrylite, Lucite, Perspex | Lexan, Makrolon, Tuffak |
| Density | ~1.19 g/cm³ | ~1.20 g/cm³ |
| Light transmission (clear, 1/8 in) | ~92% | ~88% |
| Tensile strength | ~62 to 76 MPa (9 to 11 ksi) | ~62 to 70 MPa (9 to 10 ksi) |
| Notched Izod impact | ~0.3 to 0.5 ft-lb/in | ~12 to 17 ft-lb/in |
| Surface hardness | Rockwell M ~90 to 100 | Rockwell M ~70 |
| Heat deflection (264 psi) | ~90 to 100 °C | ~130 to 140 °C |
| Max continuous service temp | ~70 to 90 °C | ~115 to 120 °C |
| UV behavior | Stable, does not yellow | Yellows and embrittles unless UV-protected |
| Flammability (typical) | UL 94 HB, burns | UL 94 V-2 or HB by thickness; FR grades V-0 |
| Relative sheet cost | Lower | Higher |
Typical values for clear, unfilled general-purpose sheet. Grades, thickness and manufacturer change the numbers, so use the supplier data sheet for a critical part. The strength numbers are close; impact is where the two separate.
Impact strength vs scratch resistance
Tensile strength barely separates them. Impact does. In a notched Izod test, polycarbonate absorbs on the order of 30 times the energy acrylic does. Hit a polycarbonate guard and it dents or bends. Hit an acrylic panel the same way and it cracks, often with sharp pieces.
Acrylic wins the surface. It is noticeably harder, so it resists scratching and scuffing from cleaning and handling, and it polishes back to clear if it does get marked. Uncoated polycarbonate scratches easily, which is why polycarbonate for windows, face shields and displays is often bought with a hardcoat on one or both faces. That hardcoat adds cost and can be damaged by some cutting and bending operations, so mention it on the RFQ.
The working rule: if anything will hit, drop or lean on the part, use polycarbonate. If it will mostly be looked at, touched and cleaned, use acrylic.
Clarity and UV
Clear acrylic transmits about 92 percent of visible light, slightly more than polycarbonate at about 88 percent, and stays optically cleaner through thick sections. For light guides, lenses, display cases and edge-lit signs, that difference shows.
Acrylic is also inherently UV stable. Standard clear acrylic left outdoors for years stays clear. Uncoated polycarbonate yellows and loses toughness in sunlight, so outdoor polycarbonate should be a UV-stabilized grade or have a UV-protective cap layer. If a part lives outside, put that on the drawing for either material.
Which to laser cut and which to route or machine
This is where the choice changes the quote.
Acrylic is the material CO2 lasers cut best. The laser vaporizes it cleanly and leaves a glossy, flame-polished edge in one pass, with no secondary finishing. Many shops laser cut acrylic up to about 1/2 in (12 mm), with tolerances typically around +/- 0.005 to 0.010 in. For flat signs, display parts and covers, laser cutting is usually the cheapest route.
Polycarbonate does not laser cut cleanly in most shops. Under a CO2 laser it chars and discolors, leaving a yellow to brown, rough edge, and it gives off heavy smoke. Thin film can be cut with a poor edge, but for most parts shops route, machine or waterjet cut polycarbonate instead. A routed polycarbonate edge is clean and square but matte, and it can be polished if it shows.
Acrylic routes and machines well too, in cast grades especially, and routing is the better choice for thick acrylic, large panels and edges that must be square with no laser taper. Routed acrylic edges come off matte and need flame, buff or diamond polishing to go clear.
| Process | Acrylic | Polycarbonate |
|---|---|---|
| CO2 laser | Best choice for flat parts to ~1/2 in; polished edge | Usually avoided; chars and discolors the edge |
| CNC routing | Good, especially cast; edge needs polishing to go clear | The usual process for sheet parts; clean, matte edge |
| CNC milling | Good in cast; extruded tends to gum and chip | Good with sharp tools; anneal for tight tolerances |
| Waterjet | Possible; piercing can chip, edge is frosted | Good for thick sheet; cold cut, frosted edge |
| Drilling and tapping | Brittle; use acrylic-ground drills, avoid tight taps near edges | Tolerant; holds threads and fasteners better |
If a polycarbonate part arrives as a DXF priced for laser cutting, expect the shop to quote routing instead. That is normal, not a mistake.
Chemicals, cleaning and crazing
Both materials can craze, a network of fine surface cracks, when a solvent meets a stressed area. The stress comes from cutting, machining, bending and over-tightened fasteners. Neither should be cleaned with acetone, MEK or other strong solvents.
Acrylic is attacked by many solvents, and alcohol on a laser-cut or flame-polished edge of extruded sheet is a common cause of crazing. Polycarbonate is more sensitive to environmental stress cracking from a wider range of chemicals, including some cleaners, threadlockers, aromatic solvents and alkaline products.
On the drawing: list what the part will be cleaned with and what it touches. For acrylic, specify cast or anneal after cutting if the part will see solvents or bonding. For polycarbonate, ask for annealing on machined parts with tight tolerances or fasteners.
Bending and forming
Polycarbonate can be cold formed. Thin sheet bends on a press brake at room temperature with some springback, and curved glazing is often cold curved into a frame. It can also be heat bent and thermoformed, but polycarbonate absorbs a little moisture and usually has to be dried first or it bubbles.
Acrylic cracks if you bend it cold. It is line bent on a strip heater or thermoformed in an oven, which adds a heated operation to the quote. Very tight bends in thick acrylic can whiten or stress the outside of the bend, so give a bend radius rather than a sharp corner.
Cost
Acrylic sheet usually costs less than polycarbonate of the same size and thickness, and it is often cheaper to cut because flat acrylic parts can go on a laser with no edge finishing.
Polycarbonate costs more as material, usually needs a router or mill, and can add a hardcoat or UV grade on top. Against that, a polycarbonate guard that survives being hit is cheaper than an acrylic guard that has to be replaced.
The expensive mistakes are specifying polycarbonate for a sign or display that will never be hit, and specifying acrylic for a machine guard because it was cheaper. Both get corrected later at a higher price.
What to put on the RFQ
Name the material and the grade, not just "clear plastic". For acrylic, say cast or extruded. For polycarbonate, say standard, UV-stabilized, hardcoated or flame-rated as needed.
Give the thickness, color or tint, quantity and which edges are cosmetic. Polishing every edge on a part where only the front face shows is a common source of avoidable cost.
Say where the part lives: indoors, outdoors, near heat, and what it will be cleaned with. Note whether protective masking should stay on through shipping. A DXF is enough for flat laser cut or routed parts. Send STEP or a dimensioned drawing for anything with pockets, countersinks, bends or threads.
Sources
- MatWeb, material property data for acrylic (PMMA) and polycarbonate
- ASTM D256, Standard Test Methods for Determining the Izod Pendulum Impact Resistance of Plastics
- ASTM D4802, Standard Specification for Poly(Methyl Methacrylate) Acrylic Plastic Sheet
- UL 94, Standard for Safety of Flammability of Plastic Materials
- Lexan polycarbonate sheet and Plexiglas acrylic sheet manufacturer technical data
Last reviewed by Tom Petrini
