Process & DFM

Types of Rivets vs Rivet Nuts vs Self-Clinching (PEM-Style) Fasteners

Sheet metal joints come down to two questions: can you reach both sides, and do you need a thread? Answer those and the choice between rivets, rivet nuts, self-clinching hardware and welding narrows quickly.

Tom PetriniCo-founder, OpenSpindle
Published 9 min read
TOOLBULB FORMS BEHINDPERMANENTBLIND RIVETONE SIDETOOLREUSABLE THREADRIVET NUTONE SIDEPUNCHANVILSHEET FLOWS INTO UNDERCUTSELF-CLINCHING NUTPRESS, BOTH SIDESREACH AND THREAD NEEDS PICK THE FASTENER

The short answer

Rivets join sheets permanently: solid rivets need access to both sides, while blind (pop) and structural blind rivets install from one side. Rivet nuts add a reusable thread to sheet or tube from one side. Self-clinching (PEM-style) nuts, studs and standoffs press into a punched hole for the strongest, cleanest thread in thin sheet, but need a press and access to both sides.

Start with two questions

Before comparing strength or price, answer two questions about the joint.

Can a tool reach both sides? A solid rivet needs a bucking bar or squeezer on the back. Self-clinching hardware needs a press anvil on the back. Blind rivets and rivet nuts are installed entirely from the front, which is why they dominate closed boxes, tube frames and field repairs.

Do you need to take it apart? Rivets are permanent; removing one means drilling it out. If a cover, a board or a bracket has to come off for service, you need a thread: a rivet nut, a self-clinching nut or stud, a weld nut, or a tapped hole in material thick enough to hold one.

Those answers usually leave two or three candidates. Sheet thickness, load, appearance and volume pick between them.

Types of rivets

Rivets differ mainly in how the second head is formed and from which side.

TypeHow it installsAccessTypical use
Solid rivetShank is upset by a rivet gun and bucking bar or a squeezerBoth sidesAircraft skins, structural joints, high-vibration assemblies
Blind rivet (pop rivet), open endMandrel is pulled, collapses the far end, then snaps offOne sideEnclosures, brackets, general sheet metal assembly
Blind rivet, closed end (sealed)Same, with a closed body that traps the mandrel headOne sideJoints that must keep out water or air
Structural blind rivetMandrel locks mechanically inside the body after settingOne sideTrailers, truck bodies, frames, higher shear and vibration loads
Multi-grip or large-flange blind rivetWide grip range or larger bearing flangeOne sideSoft, thin or variable stack thicknesses
Drive rivetPin is hammered into the body to spread itOne sideLight duty, plastics, nameplates
Semi-tubular rivetHollow end is rolled over by a pressBoth sidesHinges, pivots, high-volume consumer parts

Blind rivets are sized by diameter and grip range, the total stack thickness they can clamp. Order the grip that matches the actual stack, not the nearest diameter.

Rivet nuts

A rivet nut (also sold as a blind rivet nut or blind threaded insert) is a threaded sleeve installed into a hole from one side. The installation tool threads onto it and pulls, collapsing the body behind the sheet into a bulb that clamps the material. You get a reusable internal thread in material far too thin to tap.

Where they fit: tube and closed sections, thin sheet where you cannot reach the back, field installation, and finished or painted parts after fabrication. They are common in sheet from roughly 0.5 mm up to several millimeters, but each part number has its own grip range.

Watch for:

  • Spin-out. A round-body rivet nut in a round hole can spin when the screw is torqued. Knurled, hex-body or hex-hole versions resist rotation; specify one if the joint sees real torque.
  • Hole size. The hole is sized to the rivet nut body, which is much larger than the thread. Use the manufacturer hole size and tolerance; an oversize hole reduces clamp and spin resistance.
  • Setting. Under-set rivet nuts spin and over-set ones can strip or crack the sheet. Production installers use stroke- or force-controlled tools; mention it if consistency matters.
  • Back-side bulge. The collapsed bulb needs clearance behind the sheet.

For how rivet nuts compare to helical and key-locking inserts in machined parts, see threaded inserts.

Self-clinching (PEM-style) fasteners

Self-clinching fasteners are nuts, studs, standoffs and pins pressed into a punched or drilled hole with a press. The panel material cold flows into an undercut on the fastener, and a knurl or serrated collar keeps it from turning. PEM is a PennEngineering brand and the name many engineers use for the whole category; several manufacturers make equivalent parts, which is why drawings often say PEM OR EQUIVALENT.

They give the cleanest thread in thin sheet: flush or nearly flush on the back, high push-out and torque-out values for their size, and no loose hardware during assembly.

The mechanism sets the rules:

  • The fastener must be harder than the panel. Standard steel and 300-series stainless clinch hardware is made for aluminum and mild or cold rolled steel up to the catalog panel hardness limit. Stainless sheet usually needs hardware made for hard panels.
  • Minimum sheet thickness per part number. Often around 0.8 to 1.0 mm for small thread sizes, higher for larger ones. Thinner sheet does not fill the undercut and the fastener pushes out or spins.
  • Exact hole size. Clinch hardware goes in a hole of a specified diameter with a tight tolerance, not a generic clearance hole.
  • Edge and bend distance. Each part number lists a minimum centerline-to-edge distance. Hardware near a bend can distort when the part is formed, or become unreachable by the press afterward.
  • Press access to both sides at the point in the process where it is installed, usually after cutting and before or after bending depending on reach.

The sheet metal DFM guide covers how hardware placement interacts with bends.

Welding as the alternative

Welding is the other way to join sheet or add a thread. Spot welding joins overlapping sheets quickly in steel and is common in high-volume production. Weld nuts and weld studs, attached by projection or resistance welding, give a strong thread in steel. Capacitor discharge stud welding attaches threaded studs to thin sheet from one side, though it can mark the back face, which matters on cosmetic parts.

Welding adds heat, so it can distort thin sheet, burn off coatings and needs post-weld cleanup and finishing. Aluminum and stainless are weldable but need more skill and are more sensitive to distortion. Mechanical fasteners avoid the heat and can be installed after finishing. See welding and TIG vs MIG welding for process details.

Side-by-side comparison

Use this as a first filter. Values are typical starting points; the fastener manufacturer catalog governs minimum thickness, hole size and edge distance for each part number.

MethodAccessRemovable thread?Typical thinnest sheetRelative strengthRelative installed cost
Solid rivetBoth sidesNo, permanentThin sheet; check bearing and edge distanceHigh in shearMedium; labor-intensive
Blind rivetOne sideNo, permanentThin sheet; use large-flange types for soft or thin materialLow to mediumLow
Structural blind rivetOne sideNo, permanentPer grip range; usually thicker stacksMedium to highMedium
Rivet nutOne sideYesAbout 0.5 mm and up, per part numberMediumLow to medium
Self-clinching nut, stud or standoffBoth sides (press)YesAbout 0.8 to 1.0 mm and up for small sizes, per part numberHigh for its sizeLow per piece at volume; needs a press
Weld nut or studVaries: one side for CD studs, electrodes on both sides for projection weldsYesVaries by processHighMedium; heat and finishing
Spot weldBoth sides (electrodes)No, permanentThin steelHigh in shearLow at volume

Hole size and edge distance

Fastener holes in sheet metal are usually laser, waterjet or punch cut with the blank, so they cost almost nothing if they are in the flat pattern at the right size.

  • Blind rivets go in a hole slightly larger than the rivet: a 1/8 in rivet in a #30 drill size hole (about 0.129 in), 5/32 in in a #20 (about 0.161 in), 3/16 in in a #11 (about 0.191 in). Metric rivets typically take a hole about 0.1 mm over nominal. The drill size chart lists number and letter drill diameters.
  • Rivet nuts and self-clinching hardware take the manufacturer hole size for the specific part number. Put that diameter in the model, not the thread size.
  • Edge distance for rivets: a common minimum is two rivet diameters from the hole center to the edge, with a spacing between rivets of at least three diameters. Aerospace practice uses similar or larger values.
  • Laser-cut holes for clinch hardware are generally fine if the shop holds the hole tolerance; very small holes in thick material may need to be drilled or punched instead.

If the parts are finished, say whether hardware goes in before or after paint or powder coat. Coating in a clinch hole changes its size, and coating on a rivet nut thread has to be masked or chased.

What to call out on the drawing

A hardware callout needs the part, the quantity, the location and the install side. For example:

  • 4X SELF-CLINCHING NUT M4, STAINLESS, PEM-STYLE OR EQUIVALENT, INSTALL FROM SIDE A, CATALOG HOLE SIZE.
  • 6X BLIND RIVET 1/8 IN, ALUMINUM BODY, STEEL MANDREL, GRIP 0.063 TO 0.125, DOMED HEAD ON SIDE A.
  • 2X RIVET NUT M6, STEEL, ZINC PLATED, HEX BODY, GRIP TO SUIT 2.0 MM.

State who supplies the hardware, whether equivalents are acceptable, and the installation order relative to forming and finishing. In the CAD model, show the hole at the hardware manufacturer size and, if you can, include the fastener as a separate body or in an assembly so its position and side are unambiguous. On an OpenSpindle RFQ, tick Inserts under Secondary operations for rivet nuts and self-clinching hardware and enter the total count, then list each type in the note. Rivets themselves are usually part of an assembly scope, so describe them in the note.

OpenSpindle matches the job to a sheet metal fabrication partner shop with the press and installation tooling for the hardware you specify, and you get one matched quote that includes it.

Sources

  • FAA Advisory Circular AC 43.13-1B, Acceptable Methods, Techniques, and Practices: Aircraft Inspection and Repair
  • PennEngineering PEM self-clinching fastener catalog
  • IFI Fastener Standards, Industrial Fasteners Institute

Last reviewed by Tom Petrini

Let us quote your next part.

Upload your CAD or drawing and tell us your budget. We source it across our global network of partner shops and come back with your best-match quote, typically within about 24 hours.

  • Free quote in about 24 hours
  • No minimum order
  • No account needed to start
Add your CAD filesUp to 30 files per quote
Upload files & get a free quote

STEP · STL · IGES · DWG · DXF · SLDPRT · and more

No CAD file? Describe your project instead

Frequently asked questions

What are the main types of rivets?

Solid rivets, which need access to both sides and are upset with a rivet gun and bucking bar; blind or pop rivets, which install from one side by pulling a mandrel; structural blind rivets, whose mandrel locks inside for higher strength; drive rivets, set by hammering a pin; and semi-tubular rivets, rolled over by a press.

What is a rivet nut?

A rivet nut is a threaded sleeve installed into a hole from one side. The tool pulls on it and collapses the body behind the sheet, clamping the material and leaving a reusable internal thread. Rivet nuts are used in thin sheet and tube where the back side cannot be reached.

What is a PEM fastener?

PEM is a PennEngineering brand of self-clinching fasteners, and engineers often use the name for the whole category. A self-clinching nut, stud or standoff is pressed into a punched or drilled hole; the sheet cold flows into an undercut on the fastener, locking it in place. Equivalent parts are made by several manufacturers.

Rivet nut or self-clinching nut?

Use a self-clinching nut when a press can reach both sides during fabrication and the sheet meets the catalog minimum thickness; it is stronger for its size and flush. Use a rivet nut when you can reach only one side, in tube, or after the part is finished and assembled.

What size hole does a 1/8 in pop rivet need?

Typically a #30 drill size hole, about 0.129 in. A 5/32 in rivet usually takes a #20 hole, about 0.161 in, and a 3/16 in rivet a #11 hole, about 0.191 in. Check the rivet manufacturer data for the recommended hole range.

Can self-clinching fasteners go in stainless steel sheet?

Only hardware rated for hard panels. Standard self-clinching fasteners must be harder than the sheet, so they suit aluminum and mild steel. Stainless sheet usually needs hardened 400-series or precipitation hardened stainless clinch hardware designed for it. Check the catalog panel hardness limit.